A doom-y, pessimistic, emotional rambling on San Francisco.
I lived in and have loved San Francisco from 2004 to 2024. Every day I don’t live there feels like it puts another hundred miles between it and myself. New York’s politics are stupid and asinine, but San Francisco makes them look like the result of long struggle sessions and a butcher with nothing but the sharpest philosophical razors.
Battles here in New York over housing take place mostly on political lines. The parts of the left that matter have decided mostly not to cede housing as a value to the right, and have embraced an all of the above strategy, pursuing immediate and structural solutions to a housing crisis, mainly protection of rent stabilized tenants, prosecution of bad landlords, and, mostly importantly, building more housing. I look west at the fair city of my birth and see a left increasingly letting a coalition of “moderates,” business guys and techno-fascists eat their lunch. I see a city unable to prepare itself for the reality of a diminished silicon valley, a right who came to prominence on the backs of a nominally pro housing movement courting the vote of west side conservative NIMBYs, and a level of fecklessness from City Hall and political leadership regarding the fate of Muni that threatens the very infrastructure that holds the city together.
I see a city where the right and the left, neither motivated by any sort of political or economic theory, down poison pill after poison pill washed down with aesthetic panic while a city flounders. I see a city where the left peddles nativism with the same fervor as the right, taking no steps back to think about what that might be doing to the people they nominally work to protect. It sucks.
I see a DSA burning out my friends and failing to produce any outcomes. I see movements I fought to build falter as attention shifts to fight a right whose rise the lefts inaction allowed. I see things that make me thankful to have left, things that make me weep as I feel like I lose the city of progressive hope and pride of my childhood, that shining beacon of acceptance that beckoned to queers, freaks, revolutionaries, artists, chefs, bolt twiddlers and bike tinkerers. I don’t know how to square my beliefs that the most effective way to deliver change for marginalized people is to win with a left in my hometown that seems unwilling to even try to win if it means making any aesthetic concessions or interrogating their own biases.
I don’t know what the point of this piece is other than to say this all makes me sad. I hope that someday I can return to my city by the bay and see a coalition of progressives working to deliver progress, some billboards for boring things like personal injury law and a transit system that doesn’t have to cede anything to Google’s robocars to survive. It’s hard to feel optimistic under these conditions, and my attachment to this faltering city is poisoning my thoughts on New York, a very different political environment.
To my friends still there, please keep fighting, and keep your eyes on the prize. I love you for fighting for the city that I love more than anything. And housing folks, maybe it’s time to kick Gary Tan out of the coalition.
— 13:54